Tony’s Butt Shack BBQ & Catering Menu
Welcome to Tony’s Butt Shack BBQ & Catering, where flavors meet fun in the heart of Hollowayville, IL. Known for its mouthwatering BBQ and vibrant atmosphere, this spot offers a delicious menu that caters to all palates and occasions.
- Signature Butt Shack Sandwiches: Sink your teeth into the ChixSanity with its spicy twist, or try the indulgent Drunken Chicken, featuring bacon beer cheese.
- Satisfying Pasta Dishes: Enjoy a comforting Tortellini Dinner or Fettuccine Alfredo, each paired with fresh salads and garlic bread.
- Welcoming Atmosphere: With options for delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, it’s perfect for gatherings and families.
From the tasty Irish nachos to friendly service, Tony’s Butt Shack is a must-visit for BBQ lovers!
Butt Shack Sandwiches
Chix-Sanity
Hand-battered chicken breast dipped in nashville hot bbq sauce, topped with ghost pepper cheese, coleslaw, and pickles
Drunken Chicken
Hand-battered or grilled chicken topped with pepper jack cheese, crispy bacon, and our bacon beer cheese.
Cuban
Smoked ham, pulled pork, swiss cheese, and mustard aioli on texas toast.
3 Cheese Brisket Melt
Texas brisket on texas toast, smoked gouda, cheddar, and jack cheese.
Hot Pork-T
Pork tenderloin served over texas toast and garlic mashed potatoes smothered in gravy. no additional side included.
Pork-T
Illinois valley favorite | with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onion.
Chicken Sandwich
Hand battered or grilled.
Nashville Hot Tacos
Signature pulled pork in a crispy fried shell, with creamy coleslaw, nashville hot bbq, and sliced pickles
Crunchy Fish Tacos
Hand-breaded white fish served on soft shells, with our secret sauce and creamy coleslaw
Smoke House Tacos
Three soft shells topped with your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken, cole slaw, jalapeños, and our house bbq sauce (no side).
Taco Reuben
Tender corned beef in a crispy fried shell, topped with sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and 1000 island.
Taco's
Appetizers
Hand Battered Appetizer
Pick 1, 2 or 3 of your favorites. these are hand battered and fried.
Hillbilly Nacho
Nacho cheese doritos topped with pulled pork, shredded cheese, bbq sauce and jalapenos
Tavern Chips
Alfredo.
Garlic Cheese Curds
Fresh green onions, cauliflower and onion straws lightly fried with a hint of buffalo style seasoning. served with our nickel sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with ranch or marinara.
K.C. Skins
Deep fried potato wedges, topped with our signature pulled pork, cheese, bacon, chives and sour cream.
Brisket Totcho
Tater tots topped with smoked brisket, smothered with homemade cheese sauce, bacon, sour cream and chives.
Irish Nachos
Hand sliced Potatoes, fried and smothered with swiss cheese, corned beef, sour croute and 1000 island dressing
ABT/ Fatty Combo
3 ABT's (jalapeno stuffed with sausage, cream cheese, wrapped in bacon)2 FATTIES (diced jalapeno and cream cheese stuffed in a sausage ball, wrapped in bacon)
Rib Dinner
W/ 2 side choices
3 Meat Combo
Your choice of 3 meats and 2 sides | pulled pork, pulled chicken, smoked ham, texas beef brisket, smoked shaved pork loin, 1⁄4 smoked bbq dark chicken, 1⁄4 st. louis ribs, smoked polish sausage
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled pork sandwich is topped with coleslaw
Meatloaf Dinner
Homemade smoked meatloaf served with garlic mashed potatoes and bacon green beans
Tony's Signature Smoked Meats
Butt Shack Burgers
Double Jalapeño Mac Burger
Two patties, topped with american cheese, onion straws, bacon, bbq sauce and jalapeño mac and cheese.
Beer Cheeseburger
Two patties, topped with american cheese, bacon, grilled onions and bacon beer cheese.
PB&J Burger
Burger topped with peanut butter, bacon jam and bourbon sauce served on a potato bun
Insanity Burger
1/2 lb burger on a potato bun topped with ghost pepper cheese and deep fried pickles
Cowboy Burger
Burger topped with american cheese, onion straws and BBQ Sauce, served on a potato bun
Moink Burger
Burger topped with american cheese and pulled pork on a potato bun
Mushroom Swiss Burger
1⁄2 pound patty with sautéed mushrooms & swiss cheese.
Tortellini Dinner
With side salad and garlic bread.
Fettuccine Alfredo
With side salad and garlic bread.
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
With side salad and garlic bread.
Pasta
Salads and Wraps
Classic Chicken Salad
Mixed greens with tomato, onions, cheese, and croutons. choice of grilled or hand-battered chicken.
Brisket Cobb Salad
Mixed salad greens, red onion, egg, fire roasted veggies, tomato, fried onions, jalapeno bacon topped with texas brisket. we suggest our house dressing
Tony's Chopped Salad
Mixed greens with fresh scallions tomatoes, cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, and grilled chicken breast tossed in our house dressing.
Smoke House Wrap
Choose our pulled pork or pulled chicken, cheese, lettuce, coleslaw, jalapeno caps and bbq sauce.
South West Wrap
Grilled chicken, lettuce, fire roasted veggies, pepper jack cheese, tomatoes, and nickel sauce
Sides
Add an extra side.
